The Operation of the In Camera Rule in Family Law in Ireland (2024-present)

The operation of the in camera (privacy) rule in Ireland has been a contentious source of debate and discussion for some time now. Whilst there appears to be a general understanding that in the family law context the in camera rule operates to protect the identity and privacy of the parties and any child(/ren] to whom the proceedings relate, the actual nature and scope of the rules application is unclear. This research examined how the in camera rule works in practice in Ireland and how it is experienced by those who use and work within the courts. This research has been commissioned by the Department of Justice and was conducted by researchers from UCC (Dr Aisling Parkes (PI), School of Law; Dr Kenneth Burns, School of Applied Social Studies, UCC) and TCD (Dr Simone McCaughren, School of Social Work and Social Policy). The first phase involved a nationwide survey of parents who have been involved with the Irish family law system (317 people completed the study). The second phase involved engagement with other professional stakeholders such as social and legal professionals, services, Judges, researchers, journalists and media, and examined how they experienced the strengths and perceived limitations of the in camera rule in practice. 13 judges and 84 professionals took part in phase two. This research has the potential to have a significant impact on future family law reform by identifying the challenges and opportunities surrounding the rule’s operation. All enquiries to Aisling at a.parkes@ucc.ie Research Funding: Department of Justice