• Scientific or scholarly rigor, including the strength of the methodology, analysis, and conclusions.
• Adherence to ethical standards and best practices in research and publication.

Originality & Innovation

• Novelty and creativity of the research question, approach, or findings.
• Contribution to advancing knowledge in the field.

Impact & Significance

• Potential or demonstrated impact on the academic community, industry, or society.
• Relevance and timeliness of the research topic.

Student Contribution

• Demonstrated role of the undergraduate student in the research and publication process.
• Evidence of the student's intellectual contribution, such as data collection, analysis, or writing.

Dissemination & Reach

• Quality and reputation of the publication outlet (e.g., journal, conference, book).
• Accessibility and reach of the publication to its intended audience.

Collaboration & Mentorship

• Evidence of effective collaboration between the student and senior author/supervisor.
• Role of the supervisor in mentoring the student and supporting their development.